Constructive dismissal and forced resignation explained

A forced resignation is treated as a dismissal, but the Fair Work Commission's own test is narrow and the onus is on you to prove it.

A forced resignation, also called a constructive dismissal, is when an employee has no real choice but to resign. The Fair Work Commission's own guidance puts it plainly: "A forced resignation is when an employee has no real choice but to resign." Where the Commission accepts a resignation was forced, it treats the ending of employment as a dismissal at the employer's initiative, which is what opens the door to an unfair dismissal application in the first place. The test to get there is narrow, and the onus is on the employee to prove the resignation was not made voluntarily.

What has to be true

  • You had no real choice but to resign. The Commission describes the line between that and an ordinary resignation as narrow, one that must be "closely drawn and rigorously observed."
  • You carry the onus: it is your job to prove the resignation was not voluntary, not the employer's job to prove that it was.
  • The employer's conduct must have been intended to end the employment relationship, or have had that as its probable result.

A separate question: resigning in the heat of the moment

An employer can generally treat a clear, unambiguous resignation as exactly that, a resignation. But where a resignation is given in the heat of the moment or under extreme pressure, special circumstances may arise: the Commission's guidance says the employer may then need to let a reasonable period of time pass, and may have a duty to confirm the resignation was genuinely intended if put on notice, during that time, that it might not have been. This is a different question from forced resignation. Forced resignation asks whether the employer's conduct left you no real choice. Heat-of-the-moment asks whether a resignation you clearly stated should still count once you have had a chance to cool off, where the employer had notice it might not have been genuinely meant.

The Fair Work Commission's own case examples, all nine

The Fair Work Commission's Unfair Dismissals Benchbook publishes nine case examples on its "Forced resignation" page, under its own two headings, "Forced resignation" and "NOT a forced resignation." The table below lists all nine, with the specific facts that drove each outcome, not just the result.

Case examples from the FWC's Unfair Dismissals Benchbook, "Forced resignation" page
CaseWhat happenedHeld
Marks v Melbourne Health [2011] FWA 4024A letter to the employer indicating an intention to resign in the future, sent while the employee was distressed and unwell, which the employer treated as an effective resignation.Forced resignation. The letter was not an effective notice of resignation, so the employer's acceptance of it was itself a termination at the employer's initiative.
Bender v Raplow Pty Ltd [2011] FWA 3407After an angry discussion with her manager, she believed she had been dismissed and kept attending work to serve out a notice period.Forced resignation. She was found not to have resigned, because she did not demonstrate an intention not to be bound by her contract of employment.
Hobbs v Achilleus Taxation Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 2907He gave notice of resignation after being paid under half of what he was owed in wages, over a period of 4 months.Forced resignation, due to the conduct of the employer, and a dismissal by the employer.
Love v Alcoa of Australia Limited [2012] FWAFB 6754He resigned rather than attend a scheduled meeting about company property he had admitted to police taking without authorisation.Not forced. Held on the facts to be a voluntary resignation.
Davidson v Commonwealth [2011] FWA 3610Resigned while barred from the workplace, then suspended and subject to a disciplinary investigation.Not forced by the employer.
Blair v Kim Bainbridge Legal Service Pty Ltd [2011] FWA 2720She resigned believing her employer required her to accept a lower rate of pay or resign; the employer had in fact made no final decision.Not forced. She had misunderstood the position and acted prematurely.
Ashton v Consumer Action Law Centre [2010] FWA 9356Resigned after being placed on supervisory requirements.Not forced by the employer.
Pacific National (NSW) Limited v Bell (2008) 175 IR 208Subject to a disciplinary procedure over alleged falsification of timesheets, resigned on union advice before the employer reached a decision.Held on appeal to be a voluntary, not a forced, resignation.
Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWC 3941The employer repeatedly paid her wages late, commonly one to two days, and failed to pay superannuation.Not forced. The Commission found the conduct improper, but it did not leave her with no choice other than to resign.

Case names, facts and outcomes are read from the Fair Work Commission's own Forced resignation benchbook page. They are examples, not a checklist: the outcome in each case turned on its own specific facts, not the category of conduct alone.

What this table does, and does not, tell you

These are the Fair Work Commission's own chosen teaching examples, published under its own "Forced resignation" and "NOT a forced resignation" headings to show how the test can go either way. They are not a random or complete sample of forced-resignation disputes generally, and nothing on this page treats them as one.

It settles whether you have a dismissal, not whether it was unfair

A forced resignation being accepted as a dismissal answers one question: whether the ending of employment was a dismissal, which is the gateway into an unfair dismissal application. Whether that dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable is a separate question that still has to be established on top of it.

Genuine redundancy works as a threshold question too, in the opposite direction: an unfair dismissal application cannot be made if the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy, even where the ending of employment plainly was a dismissal. Genuine redundancy: a complete bar, not a factor covers that separate question.

The 21-day deadline still runs the same way

If your resignation is later accepted as forced, it is treated as a dismissal, and the 21-day deadline applies from the day it took effect, counted the way it's covered on how the 21-day deadline is actually counted.

Where this came from

Read next

Check your deadline