Probation period and unfair dismissal: the time test that actually counts

Probation is an arrangement your employer usually sets up and sizes. The time-based condition for an unfair dismissal claim is a separate, fixed test: the minimum employment period.

Being told you're "on probation" does not, by itself, decide whether you're eligible for an unfair dismissal claim. Probation is an arrangement whose length is usually decided by the employer (Fair Work Ombudsman); it is not one of the tests the Fair Work Commission applies. The time-based eligibility condition is a separate, fixed period the Fair Work Act calls the minimum employment period (one of several conditions, all covered in the eligibility guide linked above), and it runs on its own clock regardless of what length an employer has set for probation.

What a probation period actually is

The Fair Work Ombudsman's guidance describes probation this way: "Probation periods are often implemented at the start of the employment relationship. They give an employer and employee an opportunity to check that employees are suitable for the role they've been hired to do." On length, the same guidance says: "An employer usually decides on the length of the probation period. It often ranges from 3 to 6 months, beginning from when the employee starts employment."

Probation does not switch off your ordinary entitlements. The Ombudsman is direct on this: "While on probation, employees continue to receive the same entitlements as someone who isn't in a probation period. This includes the entitlements in the National Employment Standards." And if the probation period doesn't work out, the same guidance is that the employee is still entitled to notice when employment ends and to be paid out for their unused accumulated annual leave.

The time-based eligibility condition: the minimum employment period

Section 383 of the Fair Work Act sets a fixed test with a different name: the minimum employment period. Where the employer is not a small business, it is 6 months, ending at the earlier of the time the employee is given notice of the dismissal or immediately before the dismissal. Where the employer is a small business, it is one year ending at that same point.

The Fair Work Commission's own guidance on who the law protects states the same test in more familiar terms: employees must "work for at least the minimum employment period before the dismissal (6 months, or 12 months if the employer is a small business)." Small business here means fewer than 15 employees; see what counts as a small business employer for how the headcount is worked out.

Two different things, compared

Probation periodMinimum employment period
Who decides the lengthUsually the employer (Fair Work Ombudsman)Fixed by the Fair Work Act
The usual or fixed figureOften 3 to 6 months (Fair Work Ombudsman)6 months, or 12 months for a small business employer (Fair Work Commission)
Is it one of the Fair Work Commission's stated eligibility conditions?Not listed as oneYes, it is the time-based one

Two ways the labels get confused

The first confusion runs one way: an employer telling you "you're still on probation" does not by itself rule out an unfair dismissal claim, and it does not create one either. The time-based question is whether you have completed the minimum employment period above, 6 months if the employer is not a small business or 12 months if it is, not whether your employer's internal probation policy has finished running. The Fair Work Commission's own eligibility conditions, sourced above, do not list probation status as one of them.

The second confusion runs the other way: finishing an internal probation review does not necessarily mean you have reached the minimum employment period. A probation period ending at 3 months, the shorter end of the Ombudsman's usual 3-to-6-month range, is still short of the 6-month minimum employment period at a business that is not a small business, and further short of the 12-month minimum employment period at a small business. The reverse also holds: whatever the arrangement is called, for the time-based condition, reaching the minimum employment period is what counts.

Where this came from

Read next

Check your deadline